Dr. Robert Snowden is a Professor of Psychology at Cardiff University. His research focuses on understanding, at a cognitive and behavioural level, why individuals commit violence and sexual violence including the role of psychopathy.
In his answers, Dr. Snowden addresses:
- What are implicit measurements of cognitions
- The relationships between psychopathic traits, impulsivity, and risk taking
- Research on the link between psychopathy and emotional processing
1. How did you get involved in the area of psychopathy research?
Not sure! I am really a psychophysicist (studying how we see) but was persuaded to use these skills to examine the issue of how we “spot” a dangerous person among many offenders (risk assessment). My interest then grew as I realised the importance of measuring psychopathy in this endeavour.
2. What are implicit measures, and can psychopathic traits be identified using implicit measures? If so, what are the advantages and disadvantages of using these measures?
A major problem in forensic psychology is that people may not wish to tell us about certain thoughts, behaviours, etc. (e.g., sexual attraction to children, violent impulses). I heard about how things like “racist views” might be measured by implicit techniques. In these techniques we do not ask people their views, instead they have to complete a task in which they classify pictures and words that appear one at a time on a screen. We can infer attitudes/associations that the person has by how fast they can complete these tasks when we pair two concepts. For instance, we pair pictures of Black faces with “good” (that is, positive) words, and then pictures of Black faces with “bad” (or negative) words. If the person is fast when Black (faces) and good go together, and slow when Black and bad go together, we can infer that they have an automatic association that Black is good. We thought that these techniques might be useful to examine things such as sexual attraction (do people associate sex with adults or children), or violence (do people associate violence with good or bad). We have recently used these techniques to examine how people think about themselves. We pair words that are associated with themselves (so for me the word “Robert”) with personality traits such as kindness (versus the opposite) to infer a person’s internal views of themselves. We have developed these tests to look at personality traits associated with psychopathy (e.g., meanness, boldness).
The advantage is that these techniques can measure things that people may not be aware of themselves, or that they may not want to tell others about. The disadvantage is that they take some time to measure and that their interpretation is not straightforward. For instance, such a test might reveal that a person holds negative implicit views about Black people, but this does not mean that this is their “explicit” view or that they would behave in a racist way. Research is trying to show when and where these implicit views might influence people’s behaviour so that such measures might help us look at things like treatment changes, or attitude change – but we are some distance from being able to test an individual and say whether they are “psychopathic” or not.
3. How is psychopathy related to risk-taking and impulsivity?
I’ll take these in reverse order (as I think they are different things). When I was being trained on psychopathy, impulsivity was one of the items we are asked to consider as those with psychopathy are believed to be impulsive. However, this seemed to us at odds with what we saw in some of our offenders who had the most psychopathic traits. These people seemed to plan their actions and rarely acted on impulse. So, we studied different aspects of impulsivity, and how they were related to different aspects of psychopathy. We showed that impulsivity-related strong emotions (or “urgency” as it is known) were indeed associated with high levels of Factor 2 psychopathic traits (“behavioural instability and antisocial acts”). However, those with high levels of Factor 1 psychopathic traits (interpersonal and affective traits)did not show this – indeed, their scores tended to be lower than other offenders. Hence, individuals with elevated Factor 1 scores appear to have little emotion and do not act on emotions. These individuals plan their actions (including antisocial acts) and commit them with little emotion (cold-blooded). We think this makes then more dangerous.
Risk taking is hard to measure. However, we have used a simple laboratory task to try to do so. We get a person to blow up a (computer) balloon. They get points for each pump of air they add – but on any pump the balloon may burst and, if this happens, they lose all the points. Hence, each pump is a “risk”, and we can see if some individuals are more risky than others. We did this and measured people’s levels of psychopathy. We found that most aspects of psychopathy (such as being cruel, unempathic, impulsive, or antisocial) were not related to risk taking. However, traits known as “boldness” or “fearless” were related, such that these “fearless” people selected more pumps of air (and burst more balloons!). So, psychopathy on the whole is not related to risk taking, but some psychopathic people do show little fear, and these are the ones who are likely to undertake risky behaviours – presumably as they do not fear the consequences of these actions like most people do.
4. What features of psychopathy are most strongly related to deficits in emotional processing?
There is a large amount of research on emotional problems and psychopathy – yet we still do not have a clear picture of what is happening. Do they not perceive emotion in others? Do they not feel emotions themselves? Do they feel the emotions but simply choose to ignore them?
Our own research has tried to look at how emotions automatically affect a person. We have used two techniques. In one we look at the pupil of the eye. When a person sees an emotional image (such as a threatening animal) their pupil gets larger. We found that this response was strongly blunted in people with psychopathy related to Factor1 traits (interpersonal and affective). This finding suggests these images do not produce the normal physiological arousal in people with psychopathy.
The second technique involves showing similar emotional pictures (which the person tries to ignore) and then a target stimulus that they need to respond to. For most of us, the emotional picture grabs all our attention, and we are then poor at spotting the target. Perhaps unsurprisingly, these emotional pictures did not produce the same effects in those with elevated levels of psychopathy. In particular, we were able to show that the traits related to a lack of empathy and a lack of emotions were the ones that produced the largest effects. This result shows that some emotions are not automatically processed in such individuals.
5. Considering research is generally ahead of application in the field, what is one improvement in the field of psychopathy that you hope to see take place over the next five to ten years?
Two related wishes. My laboratory has tried to find ways that psychopathy could be measured by behavioural markers rather than by clinical opinion. Refinement of these could lead to a situation where there is a more objective measure of psychopathy so that problems might be noticed as a younger age where we could intervene and help people. The advent of brain scanning seemed like it would be able to do this – but results have been disappointing and we do not yet have a clear profile that is related to psychopathy. Yet, the traits and behaviours we associate with psychopathy must be manifest in the brain and its activity – so I still believe that we will find this profile. Maybe we have yet to look in the right way in the right places.
6. What do you want victims or survivors to know about your research?
In order to help prevent people being victims we need to know “why” the psychopath behaves as they do. We have good descriptions of their behaviour but often lack an understanding of why. I hope my research has added to a better understanding of why people commit antisocial acts and this in turn will lead us to better management and prevention of such acts.